Midnight Sun

For those who read it what did you think?? personally i didn't like it... the first chapter was great but the rest was just sort of blah... like it needed something more. i mean we already know whats going to happen so SM needed to go beyond what we already know and i just don't think she did that. i'm kinda glad she isn't publishing it cause i would be dissapointed if i had to pay to read twilight again.

I really want to read the whole side of edwards pov..
that will really be a big novel

i hope she re-writes the entire thing cause if you read the 12 chapters she has now you wouldn't like it

oh? i only read the first chappy.. when it came out.. no i think i will wait and be surprised on that one
any idea when she will release it?

i honestly don't think she will and thats fine by me cause i'd rather her move on to somebody elses story.

well, i can tell it was unfinished. I wouldnt recomend anyone read it who hasnt. because it stops at the point where it gets GOOD! AND IT WONT SCROLL DOWN!!!!!!!!!!! I guess it wasnt that impressive. But if she finishes it i will buy it and i will read it. And like you creamy I want all books in Edwards POV. New Moon would be extra dark and scary for him. Also i would be sad. But the rest....

good point and now that you mention it i would like to know what happened to him during that time he was gone. but i already know the rest of the story so unless something new will be brought to the table then lets not beat a dead horse.

I read part of the first chapter but had to stop because I didn't like it...but I'd be willing to give it another chance if it was released.

Blushing Pink wrote:well, i can tell it was unfinished. I wouldnt recomend anyone read it who hasnt. because it stops at the point where it gets GOOD! AND IT WONT SCROLL DOWN!!!!!!!!!!! I guess it wasnt that impressive. But if she finishes it i will buy it and i will read it. And like you creamy I want all books in Edwards POV. New Moon would be extra dark and scary for him. Also i would be sad. But the rest....

SM said herself tho.. seh wont do any other pov's from his perspective... she said it gave her nightmares ... haha

yeah, i heard that it would cause HER depression.

thats because other than just being a buzz killer edwards very emo

he can be. but jacob... hes warm and fuzzy,(furry) and he can have a temper but i gotta love him. he would be better.

at least you know what hes feeling cause he lets it show... edward is just too cold and controlled

cold and controlled. those are perfect words for edward.

I've only read the first chapter, and I loved it.

I wonder if she will create another series of books or something.. or maybe she will start with book 2 on host? she needs to play up Ian and the new guy

Jenna wrote:I've only read the first chapter, and I loved it.

i totally agree ch 1 was avery promising start. but if you read the rest it just wasn't as exciting

VelvetStorm wrote:

Jenna wrote:I've only read the first chapter, and I loved it.

i totally agree ch 1 was avery promising start. but if you read the rest it just wasn't as exciting

I don't plan on reading the rest unless it's released

but what if she never releases anymore than whats already been written? will you read it then?

if she releases a section of it.. for real
i will read it
but.. i also dont want to be spoiled however.. its kinda late being as twilight was already writen
haha

i'm confused... if she decides to never release more than what is on her website right now and thats all shes ever going to write you wouldn't read it??

Hard to say
knowing she aint posting anymore i really don't have to worry about i t.. I know she will write soon and then the crowds will be all over the new thing
although.. if the story is good
I will prolly peek.. * shhhh dont tell anyone I peeked*
* snort

was that an answer?? lol

VelvetStorm wrote:i'm confused... if she decides to never release more than what is on her website right now and thats all shes ever going to write you wouldn't read it??

More than likely

well thats no fun... if anynody has read it let me know what you think please!!!